Despite
ongoing debate over the value of prostate cancer screening,
a new review says it can indeed reduce a man's risk of dying
from the disease. Early tumor detection using the
prostate-specific antigen (PSA) blood test lowers a man's
risk of prostate cancer death by 25 percent to 32 percent,
the new analysis of two major trials of PSA testing found.
The amount of early diagnosis was very strongly correlated
with the reduced risk of prostate cancer death, the lead
researcher said. However, there's still a good chance that
many men will wind up treated for prostate cancer that would
not have killed them. There are definitely harms and, on
average, in a population probably five times as many men
will be over treated. It's still going to require a
discussion between a person and their doc, because of the
overtreatment problem, lead researcher added. Prostate
cancer surgery can lead to impotence and incontinence,
drastically affecting a man's quality of life. At the same
time, most prostate tumors are slow-growing, and most men
with prostate cancer wind up dying of heart disease or some
other cause. Because of this, debate has raged for years
among health care experts about whether men should be
screened for prostate cancer at all. Until about 2008, many
doctors and medical societies’ encouraged yearly screening
for men aged 50 and older using the PSA test, which examines
blood for a protein produced by cells of the prostate gland,
according to the U.S. National Cancer Institute. Elevated
PSA levels often occur in men with prostate cancer.
Unfortunately, the trials provided confusion rather than
clarity. The U.S. trial reported no benefit of PSA testing,
while the European trial found a 20 percent reduced risk of
death in men who underwent the screening. As a result, the
U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) made the
controversial move in 2012 to recommend against PSA testing
altogether. Other groups, like the American Cancer Society,
recommended that doctors share information from the clinical
trials with men and let the patients decide. |